GS的一名玩家从纯数字上进行了分析...

原帖地址：

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/fo ... p?topic_id=25884355

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I decided to take the time to see for myself if Gamespot had any bias towards any paticular console. What i did is take the top twenty games listed at Gamerankings which had at least 15 reviews for each console and simply compare the average Gamerankings score to Gamespots. The results are below.

XBXOX360

1 BioShock Gamerankings 96.2 Gamespot 90.0 GS lower -6.2
2 Oblivion Gamerankings 94.1 Gamespot 96.0 GS higher +1.9
3 Gears of War Gamerankings 93.8 Gamespot 96.0 GS higher +2.2
4 Guitar Hero 2 gamerankings92.2 Gamespot 89.0 GS lower -3.2
5 Ghost reacon Advanced Gamerankings 90.7 Gamespot 92.0 GS higher +1.3
6 Forza 2 Gamerankings 90.0 Gamespot 92.0 GS Higher +2.0
7 Call of Duty 2 Gamerankings 90.0 Gamespot 88.0 GS lower -2.0
8 Rainbow 6 Gamerankings 88.9 Gamespot 91.0 GS higher +2.1
9 Burnoout revenge Gamerankings 88.7 Gamespot 88.0 GS lower -.7
10 Project Gotham 3 Gamerankings 88.4 Gamespot 88.0 GS lower -.4
11 Elder Scrolls Shivering Isles Gamerankins 88.1 Gamespot 86.0 GS lower -2.1
12 Madden 08 GameRankings 86.6 Gamespot86.0 GS lower -.6
13 Tom Clancy Advanced 2 Gamerankings 86.5 Gamespot 87.0 GS higher +.5
14 Dead or Alive 4 Gamerankings 86.1 Gamespot 88.0 GS higher +1.9
15 Fight Night 3 Gamerankings 85.3 Gamespot 83.0 GS lower -2.3
16 Dead Rising Gamerankings 85.1 Gamespot 84.0 GS lower -1.1
17 NBA 2k7 Gamerankings 84.9 Gamespot 82.0 GS lower -2.9
18 Viva Pinata Gamerankings 84.8 Gamespot 83.0 GS lower -1.8
19 Splinter Cell DA Gamerankings 84.7 GameSpot 85.0 GS higher +.3
20 F.E.A.R. Gamerankings 83.9 Gamespot 86.0 GS higher +2.1

GS rated games higher then average 9/20 or 45% of the time.
Games rated higher averaged being 1.4 points higher then the average score
Games rated lower averaged being 2.1 points lower then the average score
Percent of games rated within 0.5 points of the average score: 15 %

WII

1. Zelda:TP Gamerankings 94.3 Gamespot 88.0 GS lower -6.3
2. RE 4 Gamerankings 91.4 Gamespot 91.0 GS lower -.4
3. Super Paper Mario Gamerankings 86.3 Gamespot 88.0 GS higher +1.7
4. WarioWare Gamerankings 81.7 Gamespot 91.0 GS higher +9.3
5. Madden 07 Gamerankings 81.6 Gamespot 84.0 GS higher + 2.4
6. Mercury Meltdown Gamerankings 80.8 Gamespot 85.0 GS higher +4.2
7. Trauma center Gamerankings 80.3 Gamespot 80.0 GS higher + .3
8. Mario Strikers charged Gamerankings 79.5 Gamespot 75.0 GS lower -4.5
9. Godfather Gamerankings 77.2 Gamespot 76.0 GS lower -1.2
10. Wii Sports Gamerankings 76.6 Gamespot 78.0 GS higher +1.4
11. Rayman Gamerankings 76.5 Gamespot 80.0 GS higher +3.5
12. Elebits Gamerankings 75.4 Gamespot 75.0 GS lower -.4
13. Excite Truck Gamerankings 75.0 Gamespot 68.0 GS lower -7.0
14. Marvel Ultimate Alliance Gamerankings 74.8 Gamespot 71.0 GS lower -3.8
15. SSx Blur Gamerankings 74.1 Gamespot 74.0 GS lower-.1
16. Tiger Woods 07 Gamerankings 73.5 Gamespot 75..0 GS higher +1.5
17. Metal Slug Gamerankings 73.4 Gamespot 75.0 GS higher +1.6
18. Super Swing Golf Gamerankings 73.2 Gamespot 68.0 GS lower -5.2
19. Super Monkey Ball Gamerankings 73.0 Gamespot 83.0 GS higher +10.0
20. Mortal Kombat Armageddon Gamerankings 72.4 Gamespot 75.0 GS higher +2.6

GS rated Wii games higher then average 10/20 or 50% of the time.
Games rated higher averaged being 3.85 higher then the average score
Games rated lower averaged being 2.89 lower then the average score.
Percent of games rated within .5 points of the average: 20%

PS3

1.Oblivion Gamerankings 92.8 Gamespot 95.0 GS higher 2.2
2. RFOM Gamerankings 87.5 Gamespot 86.0 GS lower -1.5
3. Virtua Fighter 5 Gamerankings 87.3 Gamespot 81.0 GS lower -6.3
4. Ninja Gaiden Sigma Gamerankings 86.7 Gamespot 90.0 GS higher +3.3
5. Rainbow 6 Vegas Gamerankings 86.2 Gamespot 90.0 GS higher +3.8
6. NBA street Homecourt Gamerankings 83.9 Gamespot 80.0 GS lower -3.9
7. Fight Night 3 Gamerankings 83.5 Gamespot 82.0 GS lower -1.5
8. MotorStorm Gamerankings 82.9 Gamespot 79.0 GS lower -3.9
9. Tiger Woods 07 Gamerankings 81.9 Gamespot 82.0 GS higher +.1
10. The Darkness Gamerankings 81.7 Gamespot 85.0 GS higher +3.3
11. NBA 2k7 Gamerankings 81.1 Gamespot 82.0 GS higher +.9
12. Call of Duty 3 Gamerankings 81.0 Gamespot 82.0 GS higher +1.0
13. Virtua Tennis 3 Gamerankings 80.4 Gamespot 82.0 GS higher +1.6
14. NHL 2k7 Gamerankings 80.1 Gamespot 83.0 GS higher +2.9
15. Splinter Cell: DA Gamerankings 79.4 Gamespot 80.0 GS higher +.6
16. Marvel Ultimate All. Gamerankings 79.3 Gamespot 82.0 GS higher +2.7
17. Ridge Racer 7 Gamerankings 78.9 Gamespot 80.0 GS higher +1.1
18. The Bigs Gamerankings 78.1 Gamespot 80.0 GS higher +1.9
19. Madden 07 Gamerankings 77.9 Gamespot 79.0 GS higher +1.1
20. Tony Hawk Project 8 Gamerankings 77.8 gamespot 73.0 GS lower -4.8

GS rated PS3 games higher then avg. 14/20 or 70% of the time.
Games rated higher averaged being 1.89 points higher then the average score
Games rated lower averaged being 3.0 points lower then the average score.
Percent of games rated within 0.5 of the average: 5%

Sorry if that was hard to read, i couldn't get the table thing to work quite right. So DISCUSS!


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

话说，计算的采样和方式都比较简单，参考程度有限，看一看就算了，不过就此比较看来，貌似360和PS3比较起来，GS更容易给PS3游戏高分，不会有人得出GS亲索收黑钱的结论吧...

[ 本帖最后由 tntforbrain 于 2007-8-29 20:32 编辑 ]

其实...我觉得来游戏论坛的所有人都是蛋疼的，只是谁更疼一点而已...:D

引用:

原帖由 黑龙 于 2007-8-29 23:21 发表
楼主是任饭，很聪明

错了,偶是WII+360+PC玩家,饭的话偶是个极端倒索饭...最大的乐趣就是喷天师...:D

我在主楼就说过,他的计算方法比较简单,而且采样也是,看一看就行了.

但不管怎么说,人家做了一些自己想做的事...不论怎么差,我认为起码比某些一上来就喷GS,IGN收黑钱的家伙们强多了...:D

引用:

原帖由 chovosky 于 2007-8-30 00:04 发表
果然是没知识的出来胡扯啊

非要扯到知识上么?

知识谁都有,只不过术业有专攻罢了,写那帖子的人用了自己能想到的办法,我认为不论方法如何,这种精神是值得赞扬的.

所以说我认为自己某方面懂得多一些也没什么可盛气凌人的,毕竟自己总有不懂的一方面.虽然我也看到国外的论坛对喷也不少,但你看看GS这帖外国玩家的回复和这里有什么区别吧,人家就算是否定,语气也是很柔和的.

偶自己还是某专业的博士呢...但是又如何?非自己专业与工作方面的知识甚至比其他人知道得还少,现在工作了,又把自己从前的东西忘掉不少.

虽然偶喜欢喷,但是喜欢的是那种比较好看的喷...恩...^ ^

当然,若是不懂装懂而且极其倔强的家伙,偶觉得确实是该喷一喷地...这里和LU貌似有不少这样的角色,比如某师...:D

[ 本帖最后由 tntforbrain 于 2007-8-30 01:29 编辑 ]

引用:

原帖由 level5 于 2007-8-29 20:49 发表
你不知道?

sony每个月塞1.5亿刀给GS,本来MS要塞1.6亿,可惜三红太牛B,都夕阳红了所以没钱塞.

恩,偶不知道啊,求你给个链接吧...

引用:

原帖由 爆日呆B 于 2007-8-30 01:04 发表
最客观.最权威的媒体.IGN之类没法相提并论.至于某些小岛上那RPG专门杂志的货色更没有资格比.

这个...= =

你不是LU被封无数次的霸王的大陆系列吧...

[ 本帖最后由 tntforbrain 于 2007-8-30 01:25 编辑 ]

引用:

原帖由 Jonsoncao 于 2007-8-29 21:16 发表
统计数据唯一不够科学的地方在于，应该把所有分数normalized以后，用所有分数normalize数据的一个标准差上下来衡量单个主机的分布，这是标准的统计中bootstrap方法

那位兄弟估计没怎么学过概率统计...或者是像我这样虽然学过,但也忘的差不多了...当初读研的时候还满熟的...工作后彻底荒废...= =