第一篇是Haze的review
http://www.sonydefenseforce.com/?p=442

Pros:
Awesome graphics
Splendid level design
Great pacing
Great soundtrack
Great story
Great multiplayer and co-op play
Excellent voice acting
Excellent social commentary on the horrors of war
High quality enemy and ally A.I.
Captivating gun fights
Tight controls
No loading screens in-between levels

Cons:
The main campaign is too short. We’d really want MORE of this!

Score: 10/10

Special award: FPS of the year released in May.

======================
打滚囧……这还没完……无间本姓显露还在下面……
MGS4 review
http://www.sonydefenseforce.com/?p=443

Only scientific notation can accurately express the brilliance of Metal Gear Solid 4 — Final Score: 10x10^10

===========================================


其实GTA4的review也挺搞的……
PS3版
Presentation: 9.0
Graphics: 8.3
Sound: 7.0
Gameplay: 9.8
Lasting Appeal: 10
Overall (not a weighted average): 9.4

360版
Presentation: 4.0
Graphics: 1.5
Sound: 6.0
Gameplay: 2.0
Lasting Appeal: 0 (Your Xbox 360 will die within hours)
Overall (not a weighted average): 3.5 — It’s just not quite GTA4.0….more like GTA3.5

=============================

不过去年放天剑，Lair和bioshock的review的时候这网站火了一阵，后来慢慢就淡出人们视野了……

[ 本帖最后由 Jonsoncao 于 2008-6-2 07:33 编辑 ]

这明明就是紧张大环境下的搞笑帖

MGS4 review的结语

引用:

So this presents the question: Does Solid Snake finish his mission to destroy the Xbox 360? Without question, yes. If I were Microsoft’s Aaron Greenberg, I wouldn’t be looking so green these days. The Playstation 3 has outsold the Xbox 360 for 2008 in North America, Microsoft’s strongest market, despite cosing significantly more than its competitor. The Playstation 3 is already killing the Xbox 360 in Europe and Japan. What’s worse is that it continues to sell at round parity with the Xbox 360 in North America despite massive shortages of the 80 GB PS3. With the incredible hype and pent up demand for the 80 GB SKU, you will see June sales of the Playstation 3 skyrocket and the Xbox 360 simply will not be able to recover. Combine that with firmware update 2.4 which will give Playstation games everything (and more) that Xbox Live provides but at no additional cost, and Microsoft must be sweating bullets right now (hopefully doing so on top of their overheating Xbox 360s). The release of the most groundbreaking title in the history of gaming as a Playstation 3 exclusive will push the PS3 to record heights and leave the Xbox 360 red ringing in its dust. Thank you Solid Snake. The battle was fierce for a year or so, but luckily you have killed the Xbox 360. On June 12, 2008 it truly begins.

http://www.sonydefenseforce.com/?p=257
halo3
2.5/10

http://www.sonydefenseforce.com/?p=318
马银
1/10