8.5         Presentation
Slick interface, crisp cut-scenes, online trading system and leader boards.
In-game graphics look good. Dialog is too campy.
8.5         Graphics
Really pretty. Varied level designs come to life with good art and great effects.
7.5         Sound
There's a lot of voice work and music and a good chunk of it is over-the-top campy.
3.0         Gameplay
Possibly designed by monkeys. Everything you've ever liked about Sonic games -- speed,great level designs -- is gone.
Instead, you will crawl through stages and fight enemy after enemy, with waggle.
3.0         Lasting Appeal
You can beat the primary single-player mode in a few hours and then you'll unlock some extra playable characters.
But there's no point in going back unless you like torturing yourself.
3.9
Bad         OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)

顺便，前作ign的评分是6.9，怨念爆发了？

7.5         Presentation
Beautiful opening cinematic followed by stylized, but unimpressive story sequences.
Lots of great character building elements and mini-games.
8.0         Graphics
Impressive. One of the prettiest Sonic games to date.
Surprisingly better-than-GameCube visuals run in 16;9 and 480p. Framerate usually holds up, too.
5.0         Sound
The sound effects are punchy and appropriate,
but the cheesy music and voice acting will make you wince.
6.5         Gameplay
Sometimes it's really intense and enjoyable.
Other times it's broken and frustrating.
7.0         Lasting Appeal
A healthy single-player game and a big selection of minis, but most of them are throwaways.
6.9
Passable         OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)

[Wii] Sonic and the Black Knight 　7,6,7,6 （26/40）

所以我说很可能是ign的积怨
ign之前就不是很喜欢神秘指环
玩到手再说了

另外np好像给了madworld9分