看GS吧 进游戏的也有给1分4分的
http://www.gamespot.com/diablo-iii/user-reviews/platform/pc/

仔细看了些review 这次D3惹恼的有：
老一代PC玩家：无论是制作人还是游戏玩法，火炬之光相比D3更接近经典D1
次世代PC玩家：画面过时，游戏模式和操作复古，缺乏自定义要素
网游玩家：服务器渣怎么玩
单机玩家：没有离线模式坑爹

Runic Games is a Seattle-based American computer game company formed by Travis Baldree (creator of Fate), Max Schaefer and Erich Schaefer (co-founders of Blizzard North), Peter Hu, and the Flagship Studios Seattle team responsible for Mythos.
...
One notable addition to the staff was Matt Uelmen, composer for Blizzard Entertainment's Diablo series.
...

至于D2/D3和Fate/TorchLight谁更接近D1 玩过的都知道